There's an XKCD for that, although i do think ActivityPub could be improved.
It's not a competing standard, it's a whole new approach to decentralize forum-based social media.
ActivityPub is not fully decentralized, it's a federated design, meaning it's a network of instances, and each instance is just a regular website with servers. Anyone can run an instance, but it's expensive, tiresome and you'll get banned for it; they are regular websites.
whereas Plebbit is fully decentralized, it's purely peer to peer, meaning it's a network of peers where every peer can potentially be a full node by simply using the desktop app (or in the future, a non custodial public rpc on mobile), and you don't have to run any site/domain for it, it's censorship resistant just like running a torrent with a BitTorrent client.
Also to be clear: like ActivityPub is a protocol with clients, such as Mastodon and Lemmy, Plebbit is a protocol with clients, such as Seedit and Plebchan.
Reading these comments about your work must be so hard. I remember getting this kind of feedback for my projects from know-it-alls who never completed anything themselves. Keep up the good work, decentralize everything!
So technically Plebbit is distributed then ?
Yes. Reddit is A, ActivityPub (Lemmy, Mastodon) is B, Plebbit (Seedit, Plebchan) is C:
I have just timed and 60 seconds wait time is atrocious for 8 text posts.
IPFS is nice but it doesn't make sense for things that are under few of mb
Sounds promising except the fact that IPFS runs like hot garbage.
I'm running my own IPFS stuff and unless I explicitly add my servers as peers I get about a 1 in 50 chance of finding something I pin somewhere else.
People here might be interested by my related side-project, a distributed and blockchain-less search engine for IPFS. Note that the demo server is down right now
Nifty project. Definitely I could see this being useful for discussing things that would traditionally be censored on other more centralized or semi-decentralized platforms (piracy, anti-authoritarian discussions in an oppressive country, etc).
I gave it a try and the loading times are atrocious, though. I suppose that's an unfortunate problem with running decentralized.
Definitely I could see this being useful for discussing things that would traditionally be censored on other more centralized or semi-decentralized platforms (piracy, anti-authoritarian discussions in an oppressive country, etc).
IPFS by default isn't set up to work around censorship or anything of the sort. Protocol Labs (creator/maintainer of IPFS and Filecoin) have always honored copyright takedowns, etc. on their own infrastructure and have done a fair amount of work on content blocking within the default IPFS clients and such.
e.g. https://blog.ipfs.tech/2023-content-blocking-for-the-ipfs-stack
If it is selfhosted, and text only, why use IPFS?
Because this way it has no central server, database, HTTP endpoint or DNS - it is pure peer to peer. Unlike federated instances, which are regular websites that can get deplatformed at any time, plebbit full nodes are customized IPFS Kubo nodes, and running one is as simple as downloading the Seedit client desktop app (available on github) and keeping it open. It runs the node automatically, and seeds content automatically as you browse it. It runs on a raspberry pi, so we expect to see a lot of plebbit users running their own full node.
How do you share data between nodes in a decentralised manner? IPFS is just a DHT so you can't communicate solely using it?
Maybe leave a link
Apparently https://plebbit.com/
Neat but it loads really slow and there doesn't seem to be much content beyond bitcoin stuff so far
Seedit looks like reddit to me
Text only?
Wait till people start making browser plugins for base64 images.
Lol to the cookie notice on plebbit.com
Sounds interesting
plebbit.com is just a landing page made by a member of the community, to explain the project. To use plebbit, you can check out its clients, like Seedit.
Interesting project
I din't see any benefit over our existing decentralized options. Neat idea though.
The downside is big instances decide which content to show their users. If lemmy.world defederates some instance that's content I would never know existed.
So... sounds like you need a new instance? One that doesn't defederate from all the content banned by another instance.
Technology
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related content.
- Be excellent to each another!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed